Combine water, molasses and soda. In our October issue we listed the Top 10 Best Places for Pie in America. Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie: A Taste of Amish Country. For the dry bottom version, this molasses pie is baked until the filling … This pie is just what your coffee break needs. Nothing says “Pennsylvania Dutch” like Shoofly pie. Combine first four ingredients, using hands to work into crumbs. The primary ingredients of the filling are molasses, flour, brown sugar, egg, and water. Dry Bottom Shoofly Pie Ingredients. dry bottom. There are two types of shoo fly pie, wet bottom and dry bottom. Wet bottom shoofly pie has a gooey molasses bottom with a cake-like texture on top, followed by the crumb topping. Mix flour, brown sugar, and shortening with a pastry blender. https://whatscookingamerica.net/History/PieHistory/ShooflyPie.htm This wet bottom Pennsylvania Dutch Shoofly Pie is the perfect pantry pie recipe. Spoon the rest into the unbaked piecrust. Here's the difference: wet bottom. It comes in two different versions: wet-bottom and dry-bottom. Wet-Bottom or Dry-Bottom? The strong molasses flavor is tempered with butter and a warm-spice crumble topping. Line 8 or 9" pie pan with pastry. The crumbly, cake-like nature of the pie lends itself to either layering the various ingredients to create a translucent, barely-there crust or a thicker, more substantial and traditional pie … For dry-bottom pies, generally the preference among shoo-fly bakers of the Lehigh County area of Pennsylvania, a portion of the crumb mixture is mixed or alternately layered with the molasses mixture in the pie shell and the remaining crumbs are layered on top. Reserve 2/3 cup for topping. The greatest debate over Shoofly Pie stems from whether to use a "wet-bottom" or "dry-bottom" method of preparation. Wendy Jo's absolutely delicious "wet-bottom" Shoo-fly Pie Photo by Brent Erb. We hear lots of stories about its origins and how it may have gotten its name. Shoofly pie is a molasses crumb cake baked in a pie crust. Dry bottom is the cake-like texture throughout, followed by the crumb topping. 1 cup flour; ¾ cup brown sugar; 1 rounded tablespoon shortening; 1 cup molasses; 1 egg, beaten; ¾ cup hot water; 1 teaspoon baking soda; 1 9-inch piecrust, unbaked; Directions. The main point of contention is whether Shoofly Pie should have a dry-bottom or a wet-bottom (feel free insert appropriate baby-bottom joke here). Whether it’s the wet-bottom or dry-bottom version, you will find this iconic dessert throughout Pennsylvania Dutch country and The Coal Region.A feature at many diners, bakeries, farmers’ market and road-side stands, shoofly pie is a staple throughout my beloved state of Pennsylvania. Get … All we know for sure is that it’s the perfect partner for a … The addition of a pie crust makes it easier for people to hold a piece in the hand while eating it. Quickly stir liquid into crumb mixture. The result is essentially a crumb-topped molasses cake (a lot like gingerbread, sans ginger and other spices), enclosed in a pie shell. A favorite of Amish and Mennonite cooks for many generations, shoofly pie is a classic Pennsylvania Dutch treat. If you love molasses and simple ingredients, this pie is for you. wet-bottom versus dry-bottom.